Product review

IPSY Review

Our verdict

3.6 / 5

Shop IPSY

IPSY review: a fair $15-a-month way to sample products, but 'worth up to $70' is a ceiling, $1.99 shipping adds about 13%, and there are no refunds.

Why we like it

  • Low entry price: IPSY Original is $15 a month plus $1.99 US shipping, about $3.40 per deluxe sample
  • The monthly assortment mixes indie brands with recognizable names. September 2026's pool included Tatcha, Olaplex, Benefit, Dr. Jart+ and Sol de Janeiro
  • An annual Original plan ($171 paid upfront) lowers the monthly price to $14.25
  • IPSY Extra ($32 a month) works out to under $7 per full-size product once shipping is included
  • Cancellation is self-serve from your account page, with a clear cutoff: the 25th of the month at 11:59 pm Pacific

Think twice if

  • The terms say IPSY 'does not process refunds' and doesn't accept returns of a box or any product in it
  • 'Worth up to $70' is a ceiling, and a deluxe sample's 'value' is a share of a full-size retail price, not money you save
  • Shipping became a separate $1.99 charge on US shipments in September 2025. Canadian members pay $5.95 for Original and $9.94 for Extra
  • In the Original bag you usually pick only one of five products, and the rest are assigned from your quiz
  • Disputes go to binding individual arbitration, with class actions waived

My verdict up front: IPSY Original is a reasonably priced sampling service and a poor way to buy skincare. If you treat the $15 bag as a monthly trial of products and buy full sizes only when one earns it, it’s fair value. If you sign up expecting a curated routine, or expecting $70 worth of product every month, the math and the terms will let you down. I’d rate it 3.6 out of 5. IPSY Extra is the better-value tier per product, and IPSY Ultimate makes sense for only a small group of people.

Before I reviewed finished products, I spent years on the supply side of beauty: sourcing raw materials and reading spec sheets, and watching how sample sizes get costed. That background shapes how I read a subscription box. The question isn’t “how much stuff is in the bag.” It’s what each item costs you per use, and whether you’d have bought it anyway.

This is a value and terms review, not medical or dermatological advice. Patch-test any new leave-on product before using it all over your face, and talk to a dermatologist if you’re managing a skin condition.

What you actually pay

These figures come from IPSY’s own subscribe page, terms and Ultimate FAQ, checked on October 13, 2026. IPSY has changed both names and prices over the past few years. The Glam Bag is now “IPSY Original,” BoxyCharm is now “IPSY Extra,” and the homepage still says “starting at just $14/month” while the subscribe page lists Original at $15. Expect these numbers to move.

PlanPriceWhat shipsIPSY’s value claimUS shippingRough cost per item
IPSY Original (monthly)$15/month5 deluxe-size samples + makeup bag“worth up to $70”$1.99~$3.40
IPSY Original (annual)$171 upfrontSame, 12 months“save $32”See note below~$2.85 before shipping
IPSY Extra$32/month5 full-size products“worth up to $200”$1.99~$6.80
IPSY Ultimate$65/quarter (upgrade only)8 full-size products, you choose 3“worth up to $400”Not separately confirmed~$8.13 before shipping

A few things the table doesn’t show:

  • The shipping fee used to be called something else. In mid-2022, IPSY added a $1.99 “handling fee.” Its FAQ says that starting with September 2025 shipments, it stopped offering free US shipping and replaced the handling fee with a $1.99 shipping charge, so the total stayed the same. On a $15 bag, that’s 13% on top of the advertised price. The real monthly cost of Original is $16.99 before tax.
  • The annual plan’s “$32 savings” doesn’t come from the base price alone. Twelve months at $15 is $180, so paying $171 upfront saves $9 on the subscription price. Saving $32 would also require skipping roughly a year of $1.99 shipping fees. IPSY’s page doesn’t spell that out, so confirm what the annual plan includes at checkout before you assume shipping is covered.
  • Canada costs more to get. IPSY lists Canadian shipping at $5.95 for Original and $9.94 for Extra, including customs fees. At $5.95, shipping is nearly 40% of the Original price.
  • Ultimate can’t be bought alone. It’s an upgrade to Original or Extra. It ships in February, May, August and November, and IPSY’s FAQ says it replaces your regular shipment in those months.

The “worth up to” number, read like a supplier would

When a brand puts a deluxe sample in a subscription bag, the “value” printed next to it is almost always prorated. Take the full-size retail price, divide by the full-size fill, and multiply by the sample’s fill. A sample a quarter the size of a $68 cream gets “valued” at $17. Nobody paid $17 for it. For many brands, sampling is a marketing expense. They supply the product to the box cheaply or at no charge, because putting a sample in front of a targeted customer costs less than an ad that may not convert.

That doesn’t make the samples worthless. It means the stated value only becomes savings if you would have bought those exact products at full retail price. For most people, most months, that’s true of one or two items at best. “Up to” matters too. $70 is the top of the range, and some months, depending on which items you’re assigned, the total will be lower.

A more honest way to judge a bag is by cost per use. A deluxe skincare sample typically gives you somewhere between a handful of applications and a couple of weeks of daily use, depending on the product. At about $3.40 per item, the bag is paying for trial access: enough uses to tell whether a texture pills under sunscreen, or whether a scent bothers you, before you spend $40 to $70 on a full size. Judged that way, $16.99 is reasonable. Judged as a stockpile, it isn’t.

What turned up in a recent bag

IPSY publishes each month’s collection. September 2026’s Original pool had more than 30 items, and each member got 5 of them. Skincare and haircare made up a decent share:

  • Tatcha The Dewy Milk Moisturizer
  • Olaplex Nº.5 Leave-In Conditioner and a Weightless Nourishing Mask
  • Dr. Jart+ Ceramidin Skin Barrier Moisturising Sheet Mask
  • Goldfaden MD Needle-less Line Smoothing Concentrate
  • Yensa Beauty Pink Lotus Peptide Renewal Eye Cream
  • Bliss Pore Patrol Flower Blemish Patches
  • Benefit The POREfessional Pore Primer
  • Amika Soulfood Nourishing Hair Mask

The rest of the pool leaned on makeup (mascaras, lip tints, highlighters, eyeshadow palettes), several perfume samples and a face brush. It’s a reasonable mix, but the range matters more than it looks. If your quiz results point you toward Tatcha and Olaplex, the bag feels generous. If you get a brush, a highlighter shade you’d never wear and a perfume vial, it doesn’t. IPSY doesn’t publish sample sizes on the collection page, so you can’t check the fill before the bag arrives.

The skincare problem

This is where my verdict hardens. A subscription box can’t tell you what you’re applying in any useful detail. Compare the products above with what we usually recommend on SerumSavvy: brands like The Ordinary and Paula’s Choice that print the active percentage on the label. In an IPSY bag, you might get a “line smoothing concentrate” or a “peptide renewal” eye cream. If the brand publishes no concentrations, the bag can’t either. And you didn’t choose that product based on your current routine.

That creates two practical risks. First, stacking actives you didn’t plan for. If you already use a retinoid or an exfoliating acid, a new serum can add a second strong active without your noticing. Check the full ingredient list (usually on the brand’s site) before applying anything. Second, fragrance. Perfume samples are a regular part of the pool, and many skincare and body items contain added fragrance. If you know your skin reacts to fragrance, mark that in your beauty quiz and still check every label.

None of this makes IPSY dangerous. It makes it a discovery tool. If you’re managing acne, rosacea, eczema or any other diagnosed condition, a box of random actives is the wrong tool. That’s a conversation with a dermatologist.

Choice and personalization

New members take a beauty quiz, and IPSY uses it to choose your “IPSY Picks.” Ultimate is the clearest case. IPSY’s FAQ says you get five IPSY Picks and choose the other three full-size products during a build window from the 1st to the 4th of the drop month. For Original, third-party reviewers consistently describe choosing one of the five products in a short window early in the month. If you miss the window, IPSY picks for you.

One choice out of five is not much control. In practice, the quiz does most of the work, so it’s worth being blunt and specific: skin type, the shades you’d actually wear, fragrance tolerance, and whether you want haircare at all. A quiz left vague gives the matching system almost nothing to go on, so you’ll likely end up with generic picks from the middle of the assortment.

Extra and Ultimate, briefly

IPSY Extra is the better product-for-money tier if you’d actually use full sizes. At $32 plus $1.99 shipping, five full-size products cost about $6.80 each. That’s cheap for prestige makeup or haircare, and for full-size skincare it can be very cheap. The catch is the flip side of the same coin. A full-size product you won’t use is worth exactly nothing, and you get no samples to try first. Extra suits someone who already knows their preferences and wants a monthly restock gamble. It’s the wrong tier for someone still figuring out what works.

IPSY Ultimate at $65 a quarter for eight full-size products comes to about $8.13 an item before any shipping, and three of the eight are your choice. Because it replaces your regular shipment in drop months, a year of Original plus Ultimate would be roughly eight Original bags and four Ultimate boxes. At current prices, that’s about $380 before shipping and tax. That’s a lot of product and a lot of money. It only makes sense if you use up makeup and haircare quickly.

The terms you’re agreeing to

This section gets skipped in most IPSY reviews, and it’s what I’d want a friend to read first. From IPSY’s Terms of Use, last updated July 1, 2026:

  • The subscription renews automatically and bills “indefinitely” until you cancel.
  • To avoid the next monthly charge, cancel on or before the 25th at 11:59 pm Pacific. Miss it by a day, and you’ll be billed for and receive the next box.
  • No returns and no refunds: “IPSY also does not process refunds,” and it won’t take back a box or any individual product.
  • IPSY may change prices with notice to existing subscribers.
  • Disputes go to binding individual arbitration through the American Arbitration Association, with class actions waived.

Cancelling is self-serve. Log in, go to Your Membership, and select Cancel Membership. That’s better than services that make you call or chat. If you hold more than one tier, make sure each one shows as cancelled. Reviewer sites rate IPSY’s customer service poorly, mostly over shipping delays and disputed charges. I’d screenshot your cancellation confirmation.

How it compares to just buying samples

The realistic alternative to IPSY isn’t another box. It’s buying the one or two products you’re curious about in travel or mini sizes from a retailer, or using a retailer’s free-sample-with-purchase offer. That route costs more per item, but you only pay for things you chose, and returns policies at most major beauty retailers are far more generous than “no refunds.”

IPSY wins when you genuinely enjoy surprise and want to try things you’d never pick yourself. It especially wins for makeup, where a deluxe mascara or lip product is a fair test. It loses when you already know your skin, your actives and your shades, because then most of every bag is filler you’re paying $3.40 apiece for.

Who should subscribe, and who shouldn’t

Reasonable fit:

  • You like discovering new brands and treat the bag as a trial service, not a shopping spree.
  • You use makeup and haircare quickly, so even unplanned items get used.
  • You’ll fill in the quiz honestly and use your monthly choice.
  • For Extra: you already know your preferences and want full sizes at a low per-item price.

Probably skip it:

  • You’re building a deliberate skincare routine around specific actives and concentrations.
  • You’re fragrance-sensitive and don’t want to check every label that arrives.
  • You’re in Canada, where shipping adds $5.95 to $9.94 per shipment.
  • You want the option of a refund. IPSY’s terms rule that out.

Bottom line

IPSY Original at $16.99 a month, including shipping, is a fair price for five chances to try something before committing to a full size. That’s what it’s good at. The “worth up to $70” figure is marketing math, the shipping fee is a quiet 13% increase over the advertised price, and the no-refund, arbitration-only terms are stricter than many shoppers realize. Set a calendar reminder for the 24th, rate the products you get so the picks improve, and buy full sizes only of the items that earn a place in your routine.

Your questions

How much does IPSY cost per month in 2026?

IPSY's subscribe page lists IPSY Original at $15 a month and IPSY Extra at $32 a month, plus $1.99 US shipping per shipment. IPSY Ultimate is a $65-per-quarter upgrade for existing members. The homepage also advertises 'starting at $14/month,' which matches the $171 annual Original plan ($14.25 a month). Prices change, so check at checkout.

Is IPSY worth it for skincare?

As a way to try a product before committing to a full size, often yes. As a way to build a skincare routine, not really. You don't control which actives arrive, deluxe samples are often only one to two weeks of use, and IPSY doesn't publish concentrations for the products it sends. Buy the full sizes you like separately.

When do I have to cancel IPSY to avoid the next charge?

IPSY's terms say to cancel on or before the 25th of the month at 11:59 pm Pacific. If you cancel on the 26th, you'll still be billed for and receive the next month's box. If you subscribe to more than one tier, check that each one shows as cancelled.

Can I get a refund from IPSY?

Generally no. IPSY's Terms of Use (updated July 1, 2026) say it does not process refunds and does not accept returns of a box or any product in it. Third-party guides say support may replace missing or damaged items if you report them soon after delivery, but don't count on getting money back.

What's the difference between IPSY Original, IPSY Extra and BoxyCharm?

IPSY Original, formerly the Glam Bag, sends five deluxe samples a month for $15. IPSY Extra is the former BoxyCharm and sends five full-size products a month for $32. IPSY Ultimate is a quarterly box of eight full-size products, three of which you choose, for $65. It replaces your regular shipment in the months it ships.

Is the IPSY 'value' of $70 or $200 real?

It's a retail-price figure, and 'up to' means it's the top of the range, not a monthly average. A sample's listed value is usually its share of a full-size price. That only counts as savings if you would have bought those exact products at full retail price.

SerumSavvy may earn a commission if you buy through links on this page; it never changes a verdict. This is general information, not medical advice — patch-test new products and see a dermatologist about persistent skin concerns.